Eleven Madison Park Review

Ouch!

1 Like

Haha, yeah no Chinese speaking person would be impressed by that gai lan. We went earlier in the year, and I am in the dog house (“no tasting menu for a few months” and “possibly no vegetarian fine dining ever”) as a result.

4 Likes

damn, sounds rough. that dish looks lazy and awful with little understanding - gai lan looks dry and dull, just adding truffle seems lazy when the main ingredient doesn’t seem to be cooked nicely. truffle can be good but in my experience it’s a lazy crutch 85% of the time and the plating looks like it has little consideration for how the dish eats.

their switch to vegetarian comes off to me as a either marketing or naivety. i’m not necessarily doubting the chef’s sincerity on sustainability or ethical concerns, but the results of the cuisine really don’t seem to match their ambitions as a fine dining restaurant. looks like they’re phoning it in or didn’t really have a good grasp of how to execute this cuisine to begin with.

let me guess - there’s truffle, lots of small/mediocre shiitake, excess yuzu zesting, shiso, and an explanation of tonburi as “land caviar?”

not every place can be Arpège, where the balance and combinations are next-level.

2 Likes

Happy to hear about Arpège; have a reservation for May.

Yes, everything you said, except I don’t remember shiso.

It could be a brilliant strategy. Instead of buying expensive seafood, meat, and cheeses, you buy a bunch of vegetables from the farm you control. Could save $$$$.

you’re in for a treat. go all out and get the high menu if you’re willing. right from the “hot-cold Arpège egg,” you may realize the dishes are on another level compared to those imitations / homages that others have done. for the egg, it’s the balance of the sherry vinegar, maple syrup, chives, cream, and the pepper/clove/nutmeg/ginger spice off the bat. great all the way to the profiterole and mille-feuille. yes the vegetables are a revelation but so is the featured meat dish.

2 Likes