yup not in “hall of fame tier” is what I would categorize it as well. I would say that the service was much more casual and the dining environment was much warmer than Atelier Crenn, but the food and pairings at AC are better (both old and new menu).
I think if they dialled down the amount of food
to 70% of what it was, I would have enjoyed it infinitely more. I slept so badly and now I am still full 
the next morning. I legit could only eat half of the first dessert course and we got the mignardises packed to go.