Happy to write it, although we have yet to use cast iron since my re-seasoning. And I am very much a newbie w/ cast iron. Lemme explain in more detail.
I got a Lodge grill pan about 1-2 yrs ago. My first piece of new cast iron. It’s pre-seasoned, but I read on-line in forums that you should add seasoning. Heard that flaxseed oil works best (b/c of it’s low smoke point?). ATK also apparently tried it and said that it works well.
I don’t know if I just used a low-quality flaxseed oil (despite getting one from Whole Foods), but it was a MESS. When I took it out of the oven, there were sticky areas where I hadn’t sufficiently buffed it off, and it just didn’t seem to take (so flaked all over the food and came off easily when washed). Bleh.
Decided more recently to try it again w/ canola oil. Some blogs say you should start w/ a warm pan b/c it “open the pores.” Eh, whatever. I’m starting w/ room temp. I use a moderate amount of canola oil (using TJ’s) and apply all over (incl handles) and then take a clean cloth and BUFFuntil it appears that there’s barely an oil left (which is actually pretty easy w/ rags b/c the rags seem to absorb the oil very easily).
With the grill pan, you REALLY have to wipe around the ridge b/c the oil puddles very easily in those areas (and will likely create a horrific sticky goo when heated).
Stick it in the oven. Turn on the hood fan (b/c it’ll stink when the oil starts smoking). Set on 415 deg (read somewhere that taking it much beyond the smoke point doesn’t do much). When the oven hits 415, I left it go for another hr and then turn the oven off. I don’t open the oven door for at least an hour.
The grill pan, even after the first application of canola oil, has a beautiful, even, matte layer that never happened w/ the flaxseed oil. No stickiness (except in a few places around the ridges). And, when I really drag my fingers over the surface, NO FLAKING. I’m assuming that the desired level of seasoning will result in a shinier coat, but I think I should just start using the cookware more to get there.
The carbon steel just turned medium brown and is now developing tiny dark brown dots all over. seriouseats says that carbon steel takes seasoning more quickly ut also loses it more quickly. I’ve never used carbon steel before getting this pan, so we’ll see how this goes.
Not sure if we’ll be cooking any eggs, potatoes, or steaks in the near future, but, if we do, I’ll let you know how it goes! Assuming this works, it’s actually pretty easy, once you get the hang of it.